Friday, January 05, 2007

Turtles All The Way Down

According to an apocryphal story, a well-known scientist was describing to an audience how the Earth orbits the sun and how the sun, in turn, orbits the centre of a vast collection of stars called our galaxy. At the end of his lecture, a little old lady got up and said: “This is all nonsense. Everybody knows that the world is really a flat plate supported on the back of a giant turtle.”

The scientist smiled and said, “I see. Can you tell, me, then, what is the turtle standing on?”

“You’re very clever, young man,” replied the old lady with a prim smile. “But it’s turtles all the way down!”

This story neatly captures the logical foolishness of the “Infinite Regression.” It is a tale pregnant with meaning for Libertarians, for we face some version of it almost every time we open our mouths.

The appeal to political authority in all its forms is really an attempt to bypass the black hole of Infinite Regression.

Here’s a pro-state argument we are all intimately familiar with:

Bad people like to use force to prey on good people.
Good people require a government to protect them from bad people.
This government, in order to be the final arbiter, must possess overwhelming force.

The logical madness is clear. Since bad people like using force to prey on good people, and the government is the greatest concentration of force in society, it stands to inevitable reason that bad people will use the government to prey on good people.

This is the central problem of Infinite Regression: who will watch the watchers? There is, of course, no rational or political answer. (There is an anarchistic answer, which I discuss in my podcasts at www.freedomainradio.com.)

We see the same problem in theology. Since the universe exists, people claim, it must have been created. This solves nothing. If the principle is put forward: “that which exists must have been created,” inventing a god immediately triggers an Infinite Regression. A god which exists must then have been created by a super-god, who in turn must have been… Well, let’s just say that it’s turtles all the way up.

Intelligent Design, or Creationism, faces the same problem. If “all life must be created by a god,” then that god, who is clearly alive, must have also been created by another god…

Unjust parental authority faces the same problem.

I say to my son: “I am right because I am your father.”

He naturally asks: “Are you ‘right’ because you are my father – i.e. all fathers are right – or are you right because fathers possess some wisdom or knowledge that sons do not?”

“I am right because I am your father,” I repeat.

“And who taught you this?”

“My father.”

“And he was taught this by his father?” he asks.

“Yes.”

“So who was the first father to say this? And did he not disobey his own father by teaching something new? And does that not make all subsequent teachings of this rule invalid?”

Here I am generally stumped, and call him a communist. Another argument is swallowed up by the black hole of Infinite Regression.

Here’s another. People like to argue that the government should control the use of guns. Why? Because there are bad people who would use those guns to hurt us. The logical rule invoked? Well, we need a gang with more guns (the government) to protect us from gangs with fewer guns (criminals). So naturally, when the government, having gotten rid of its competition, steals our money through taxes, we logically need a World Government to disarm the existing governments. Then we will doubtless need an Interstellar Federation to, well you get the idea…

Rejecting all “arguments” based on the Infinite Regression fallacy can unleash prodigious creativity. What has been sometimes called the single greatest idea in the history of the world arose from Darwin’s failure to be impressed by the Infinite Regression paradoxes of creationism. Free markets – and economics in general – arose from the failure of Ricardo and Smith to be impressed by the Infinite Regression argument that the nobility should manage resources on behalf of everyone else.

In the realm of morality, the problems of Infinite Regression are, literally, genocidal. The fantasy that a minority of men can justly force obedience from everyone else is responsible for more deaths than any other single delusion. In the realm of morality and the use of force, there is simply no solution to the problems of Infinite Regression. A stateless society is the only answer.

Any fundamentally rational philosophy must reject arguments that pass anywhere near the black hole of Infinite Regression. Appeals to the “virtuous violence” of the state instantly self-destruct, because of Infinite Regression. Demands for “obedience to gods” instantly self-destruct, since there must then be an infinite chain of more powerful gods, all obeying the “god above,” which would instantly result in a truly bureaucratic cosmic paralysis. Even merely mortal parents who attempt to justify their commandments through appeals to power, biology or position fall into the gravity well of Infinite Regression.

The three traditional power centers – politicians, priests and most parents – all justify their authority based on Infinite Regression fantasies. If mankind continues to believe in any moral authority except logical consistency and evidence, we will continue to sail blithely over the edge of the old lady’s imaginary plate, falling forever.

As the turtles descend, so do we.

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

Excellent, as usual, Stefan. Keep them coming!

Patrick Crozier said...

OK then, who does watch the watchers? Because presumably they exist. I want somebody to round up the criminals and repel invaders and they presumably have to be armed. And if they are armed presumably they can enslave me.

bvjh said...

figli che scopano le madri
nane col cazzo
discreto ragazze merda
negre mature
americano ubriache in casa
autocoscienza infermiera ubriache
foto sborrate
guida al sesso anale
piccola capezzoli
eccellere urinate
lesbiche che godono video
handsome nonne dildo
pleasant cowgirl strip
taglio asiatiche ubriache
piu bollente moglie fotti
fresco bionde prostituta
zia lesbica nipote
bonny fighetta figa fotti
calciatori
le mie foto sex
indescrivibile fighette amore
www cd cover
strappare brasiliane
beautiful soldato orale fotti
beauty americano doppio penetrazione
fotografie di ermafroditi
guida al sesso anale
amore fighette spogliarello
sconfinato cinema
caldissimo grazioso figlia
www donne zozze
celestiale intermedio
raro infermiera
desiderio russa
sconfinato aspo
sborrate gratuito
farcical infermiera masturbate
coraggioso tedesco spogliarello
donne cinesi incinte
amatoriale pompino
intenso fighetta spogliarello
sesso con uomini neri
inglese strip in automobile
deciso filmati
ragazze maledica in anticamera
coy tedesco urinate
perfetto amatoriali sesso
racconti caldi gratis
femmine in stivali
sconfinato amatoriali azione

jomama said...

OK then, who does watch the watchers?

Who watches the watchers of the
watchers?

Ralph said...

Stefan, I always enjoy your writing. On infinite regression, let me point out something from a biblical perspective. Jesus himself directly deal with infinite regression. No really!

In Matthew 24, he was asked what the "end times" would be like, and his first warning was "take heed that no man deceive you".

His warning was aimed at false Christs and false prophets that would be everywhere. What is this but a physical manifestation of infinite regression?

The question is, if there are false leaders everywhere, and today there are over 30,000 versions of christianity, what would be the most logical choice for one seeking truth?

Choose none of them. The reason for this is due to a theorem extending from Godel's incompleteness theorem. It states, in any axiomatic system, there is an infinity of undecideable propositions, which means that if you join a religion, the best you can hope to offer is an infinity of new undecideable propositions, based on your experience.

So, did Jesus conform to this logic? In Matthew 24:23, it seems he did: "Then if any man says to you, Lo, here is Christ, or there, believe it not."

And there you have it. Jesus' condemnation of all religions that come in his name.

Anonymous said...

"...that which exists must have been created,” inventing a god immediately triggers an Infinite Regression. A god which exists must then have been created by a super-god, who in turn must have been… Well, let’s just say that it’s turtles all the way up.

Intelligent Design, or Creationism, faces the same problem. If “all life must be created by a god,” then that god, who is clearly alive, must have also been created by another god…"



I'm glad to see you understand Mormonism. Except God doesn't create other gods, per se. He takes light that has existed eternally, gives it a spiritual body, sends it to earth in a physical body, resurrects said body, and based on its behavious (acceptance of Christ or what have you) is given power to be as God who then starts the cycle anew. At least thats how it is in a nutshell.

Anonymous said...

merde abbigliamento stocchisti milano tettone francesi fiche arrapate adatto asiatiche azione foto sesso porno fresco prodigiosamente nubile portata cordless leccate di culo corsi post diploma scopate sexciottenni sesso amatoriale video clip gratis anale gratis cellulareomnitel anetta keys films it binari x erotismo coraggioso amante azione sesso anale grosso nero assurdo cowgirl azione puzzlerompicapiepoc goodly teen doppio penetrazione annunci coppie esibizioniste vergognoso fighette masturbate donne che godono in fotografia fregne con cazzi filmino sesso amatoriale privato ragazze con froci upskirt famosi prodigiosamente superpoppe urinate fare sesso venezia culi e perizomi add new link sesso orale siti erotici gay puttane con animali spiate senza mutande sesso free venezia adeguato fighetta prostituta trevisocalcio prittier lesbiche lucia amatoriale sesso attraente fighetta strip sesso orale it fstream h sesso amatoriale italiano cosce donne brutte good looking fighetta sex web hard tv porcellone cinesi

Anonymous said...

vecchi pelosi e sexy la figa di mara venier italia le porno strar figlie inculate cazzi di neri sesso fot amato attrici italiane massaggiatrici bionde spia donne seso giorgia palmas pompino moana pozzi nuda figa foto scambisti esibizioniste amatoriali free maturi sesso pompini e seghe infermiere puttane www gratis sexs film cavallo sexy seghe tettone bionde tettone e zoccole foto di mia suocera nuda culetti di spiaggia spermate video spruzzi anali pps sexi gratis madri vogliose piedi esibizionisti reggicalze perizoma figa sesso sporco gratis film studentessa arrapata 2bfoto minchie grandi ragazze bionde che sborrano minigonne 2besibizioniste figa super puttane calde sborrati telefono sexi gratis esibizioniste amatoriali suocera vogliosa trasex a paris celebrit c3 a0 fotomontaggi gratis culetto amatoriale

Anonymous said...

piu fresco more cazzi pelosi gay negri play selen hardcore pleasant superpoppe dildo ottenga sposato e pompinare infermiere calde fantasticamente lesbiche sex pompinare troie bionde piu caldo insensato padre pompini bambine video di inculate pompini con l ingoio piu fresco farsesco mamma pluvio nonsensical ragazze urinate pompinare napoletane escort neri pompinare vogliose scopate a mia madre pompini brigitta bulgari donne libere video pompini pompini di sarah young discreto madre pompini firenze gratis molto bollente pauroso mamma pompini rizzo scopate ramona piu fresco sublime castra schioccare sbronze spogliarello pleasant infermiera figa fotti immagini cazzo pocce grosse sensazione sbronze inculate pompinare negre amatorialeasi pompini %2b veline facial cumshot pompini chiavate sborra tette fighe universitarie pompini doc video erotici amatoriali pleasant inglese azione good fighetta fottilo polacche troie musica er tica pompinare puttane suocera %2bsborra%2bculo pompini al cavallo piu freddo casalinga pompini con bambine bionde sborrate pompini facciali foto di anziani che fanno sesso pompini ingoio sperma mondo troie

Anonymous said...

adultoase brytneypompini scarpe e scarpecom donne spogliarelli favoloso asiatiche merda nicer asiatiche urinate prittiest cameriera amore videochathardcatania racconti porno moglie padrona fregne sfondate mappaconcettualeesamestato descuidos sherlyn amateur super sexi friendly infermiera gruppo super sexi teen sex da montare recuperodatohd suca la fica foto la professoressa nuda canalis mutandine scooterelettrico desire fighetta urinate finanziamentogiovanicoppia donne vecchissime sexi commedia erotica mulatte brasiliane nude fichefp posizioni sexsi offertaweekend ritirarsi ragazze strip pube biondo sesso fotoscambio porcone affamate partitaivacomunitaria galgo uniformes lesbe le sexi gratis immagini succhia capezzoli foto ditalini gratis free scopato coppie con mariti cornuti racconti erotici su vip pietro taricone nudo per max lamore sexy non lo so prestitodipendentepubblico culi di esibizioniste fighettevere trans bisex segretaria pompino in ufficio scopare una casalinga divanitrasformabili mercatodiamanti sesso cazzo svedese alla pecorina capo bionde pompino disegnotatuaggio postaelettronica annuncioaci sex sex nuda carnivalcrociera fantastico fighetta inculate figa sporca hoteldianomarina nudebeach fotos desiderio bionde ass to mouth sesso spinto per adulti sensazione asiatiche pompino parigihoteleconomici ragazze brasiliane nude filmati gratis bashful bionde gruppo dianagrandefratello europaitaliasicilia vecchie vogliose troie cercasi inculate allaperto vergine pene risibile ragazze sexldo pps nude work it lyrics

Anonymous said...

guardoni sesso coraggioso fighette uomini travestiti scopate transessuali super vogliose bonny infermiera inculate momentaneo webcam clip sexuploader super fiche segretarie tettone giovani pompini filmini amatoriali neri selvaggio mature inculate erotismo pitanga donne mature dvd cazzo da cavallo culturiste italiane siti lesbiche beauty amatoriali orale fotti fresco selvaggio fighetta donne brune nude pornostars asiatiche culetto nudo donne porcelle video rifatte profilattico film eccellente ragazze amore handjob futai foto gratis guardoni in ufficio bisessuale culi enormi funny asiatiche inculate mamacitas maduras pompini molto bollente lesbiche amore famoso segretaria dildo chat eros congenial soldato strip donne con tette video poono gratis tettine hard

Anonymous said...

sborra sulle mutande amateur hardcorre sborrate parodias hentai fetish fiche bionde donne mature sex caldo piacevole bikini video scolastici nane che scopano liceali fighe divertente tedesco dildo foto hard amatoriali foto spogliarello video porno suore agenzie matrimoniali gratuite giovani fichetteit metodi masturbazione troie cinquantenni sexy metrigen fuerte pompin e seghe fotoannunci x scambisti notizie virgilio it domina porte italia fica grassa gay nudi artistici coppie libidinose cubane che succhiano foto signore mature gratis piedi odorosi figa di cavallo gosesso lesbo teen free pics shemale directory cazzi sborranti gratis comico amatoriali fotti tutta fica zie pelose jennifer aniston free galeri filmini buffi studentesse vogliose video caldo femmina spogliarello bocchini culi asiatiche fantastici cazzi negri vecchi scopano ragazze inchiodare junior gay neri sito map taglio sborrate in faccia fige pelosissime video gratis eros video diciottenni gay inculati sappic hardcore

Anonymous said...

fighe da paura mignotte anziane foto di esibizionisti nudi inculate nere nude party moglie troia reggicalze video ubriache esibizioniste pompini imagenes sadicas le tette piu belle della rete corsi di fisioterapia foto vecchie mamme moglie lesbica scopate bottiglia in bocca infermiera fotti nella residenza la repubblica storie scopate suore cazzi lunghi e grossi gratis culone negre angelica porno gratis solo trans gratis troie succhiano cazzi sybian sexuploader beautiful idraulico masturbate muscolosi pelosi asiatiche immagini lust fighetta pompino paingate alice piacevole fighetta ubriache imbarazzato cameriera amore culetti aperti mulatte zoccole foto pazze innocenti siti con vogliose belle sorche veri uomoni nudi smtp virgilio foto pompini di gruppo cristina e arrapata famoso bionde gruppo vogliose studentesse ubriache vido sexe chiappe voyeur camionisti porci guardoni pippe foto ricky nudo fica pelosissima sex piacevole lesbiche succhi slabbrata gratis

FSK said...

You should enable "comment moderation" and remove the obvious spam comments from your blog.